Mary Branscombe (marypcb) wrote,
Mary Branscombe
marypcb

  • Mood:

It's the message not the medium, stupid

I don't use Twitter (Simon does so if you tweet him and it's important enough I'll hear about it eventually). I just don't have time and the management tools aren't there and I'm more interested in reading and engaging with more fully developed ideas explored at length. (You can take it as read that I'm not suggesting anything negative about anyone who twits, tweets, retweets, twats or whatever you choose to call it, although I do have some points to make about attention economics and power relationships and if I was stuck in a lift with someone who kept twittering I would be wanting to smash their phone).

But I'm currently disagreeing violently with some friend of a friend who complained about them republishing twitters in their blog with the sweeping comment that I'll paraphrase as 'microblogging doesn't belong in a blog'. So what is the minimum acceptable length for a blog post? All your blog posts must be original and never typed in any other medium before? Sure, a list of jottings and replies to unknown questions can be cryptic or tedious, but so can full-length blog posts - and I know how to use the scroll bar and the rich features that make LJ a social blogging platform rather than just a baby CMS (filters, friends groups and default view to start with). All your blog posts must be well thought out and interesting to me personally? (That would be some other Internet I'm not currently familiar with).

With the blackout protest going on, it's ironic that at least one of the people involved is a kiwi (which is leading me into thoughts about tolerant societies and how while geeks and fen are very tolerant of sub-groups disapproved of by mainstream society they can also be viciously intolerant of sub-groups within their own culture that they deem to betray it by being too different - the OS religious wars, the litfen/mediafen snobbery). So I'm going to quote the woman everyone mistakes for Voltaire, Beatrice Hall (and don't even get me started on the commentator who said that her writing was too well-phrased so of course everyone thought it was the genius himself0: "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it" and add 'and equally, your method and medium for saying it".
Tags: quote, rant
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 2 comments